Checklist and examplesFor care teamsAny market
What evidence should a contractor provide before a defect is closed?
When a contractor reports a repair complete after handover, your customer care team still has to decide whether the case can close. This guide shows what to check, with three fictional evidence packs and a record you can copy.
Short answer
A contractor's completion report says the work is done; the evidence lets your care team check it. A useful pack identifies the case and location, restates the agreed work, describes what was actually done, includes the supporting material the work calls for and lists anything outstanding. The reviewer then records a decision. How much evidence you need depends on the work and its risk: a photo can show a replaced cupboard front, but rarely shows that the source of a recurring problem has been dealt with.
Start with the report and agreed work
Review the evidence against what was asked, not against how good the result looks. A sharp photo of a freshly painted wall answers nothing if nobody wrote down whether the job was to repaint the wall or to find out why a mark keeps coming back.
Before opening the contractor's photos, put four things side by side:
- The original observation: what the owner reported, in their words, with the home, room and location.
- The assessed work: what your team or the contractor decided needed doing after looking at it.
- Any change to that scope: extra work found on site, work dropped or a different repair agreed, and who agreed it.
- The review question: the one thing the evidence has to show, such as “the damaged front has been replaced” or “the source of the mark has been identified and dealt with”.
If you cannot write the review question in one sentence, the scope was not clear enough, and the first step is to clarify it with the contractor. The aftercare process guide places this review as the last step before closure; in the defect register template it is the Ready for review stage.
Ask for evidence that answers the review question
Ask the contractor for the material that answers your review question, grouped so the reviewer can find it. The record later in this guide uses six groups.
| Review area | What it records |
|---|---|
| Identity and scope | Case reference, home and location; original observation; agreed work; relevant scope changes. |
| Reported completion | Who reported the work complete and when; what was actually done; materials or documents that matter to the decision. |
| Supporting material | Photos where they help, with file references and who supplied them; any inspection or test records the work requires. |
| Outstanding items | Unfinished work, limitations the contractor reports, further assessment needed and the owner's own observations. |
| Review | Who reviewed and when; what was looked at; what it supports; what is still uncertain; the decision and its reason. |
| Next step | Further work or information; who is responsible and by when; how the owner was told; any related follow-up case. |
What photographs can establish
Photos are good at showing visible condition and context. A wide shot shows which home and room you are looking at; a close-up shows the detail. Together they can establish that:
- the work was carried out in the right home and location;
- a visible part was replaced, refitted or refinished;
- the surrounding area was left clean and undamaged.
Ask for each photo to carry the case reference in its file name or caption, so it cannot be mistaken for another home's. A photo cannot show how a door closes, what is behind a surface or whether a problem will return.
When other evidence is needed
Some work needs evidence that a photo cannot give: a written description of what was found, a record of an inspection or test, a manufacturer's document or an assessment by a qualified person. Which of these applies depends on the work and its risk, and that is a technical question. Ask the contractor, or a qualified person your team relies on, what would show that this particular repair is complete.
The checklist structures your review. It does not certify that work is safe or technically sound, and it does not replace the assessment a qualified professional would make.
Compare three completion packs
The same kind of evidence can support different decisions, depending on what the work was meant to achieve. The three packs below are fictional. Each shows what a reviewer could and could not conclude.
| Pack | Evidence available | Evidence missing | Decision it supports | Next action |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A: cupboard-front replacement | Case reference, the requested replacement, a dated description of the work, and a wide and a close-up photo, both labelled | Whether the door now closes properly, which the owner raised before the visit | The front was replaced as asked; the closing concern is still open | Ask the contractor whether closing was checked and confirm with the owner |
| B: unlabelled close-up | One close-up of a tile joint and a note saying “done” | Home and location, the work carried out, a wider view | None yet: the photo could belong to several homes | Request the case reference, a description of the work and a photo showing the location |
| C: recurring damp mark | One photo of a repainted wall | Any record of how the source of the mark was assessed or dealt with, which was the agreed work | The finish was renewed; nothing shows the agreed work was done | Keep the case open and ask a qualified person what evidence the work needs |
Packs A and C both rely on an after-photo. For A, the photo answers most of the review question, because the request was to replace something visible. For C, it answers almost none of it: the agreed work concerned the source of the mark, and fresh paint shows only the surface. Pack B is a documentation gap, not a judgement on the contractor. It simply cannot be matched to a case yet.
Fictional example
A repainted wall, reviewed against the agreed work
EX-C03Example development · Apartment 7 · Bedroom, below the window
Report and agreed work
- 2 OctOwner reports a dark mark below the bedroom window that has returned after cleaning
- 6 OctTeam asks the contractor to find and address the source of the mark, then make good the finish
Reported completion
- 20 OctContractor reports the job complete and sends one photo of the repainted wall
Review
- 22 OctReviewer finds no record of how the source was assessed; the photo shows only the finish
- 22 OctCase stays open; team asks a qualified person what evidence would show the source has been dealt with and tells the owner why
Fictional example. It shows a review decision only; it does not diagnose the mark or suggest a repair method.
Record the review and remaining uncertainty
Record the review as its own event, separate from the contractor's completion report. The report says what the contractor did. The review says what your team checked, what that supports and what it decided.
| Decision | When it fits | What to record |
|---|---|---|
| Close the case | The evidence answers the review question and nothing agreed is outstanding | Reviewer, date, the evidence looked at and the outcome |
| Request information | The work may be done, but the evidence cannot show it | Exactly what is missing, who will provide it and by when |
| Return for further work | The evidence shows agreed work is unfinished or not as agreed | What remains, the new next action and its deadline |
| Obtain specialist review | The question needs technical judgement your team cannot give | The question asked, who will answer it and what happens meanwhile |
Write down the limits as well as the decision. “Front replaced; closing not checked” tells the next person far more than a ticked box. Then tell the owner the outcome; the guide to updating a homeowner when the repair date is unknown covers updates while work is still open.
Evidence-review record
Copy these columns into your spreadsheet or the review notes of your existing system, one row per completion report. Fill in the first nine columns from the report and the case, and the last six when you review it. The rows show the three fictional packs from this guide.
| Case and location | Original observation | Agreed work and changes | Reported by and date | Work reported as done | Supporting material | Inspection or test records | Outstanding items | Owner's observations | Reviewer and date | What the evidence supports | Remaining uncertainty | Decision and reason | Next step, who, by when and related case | Owner informed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EX-A01 · Apartment 3 · Kitchen, cupboard left of the sink | Cupboard front swollen at the lower edge | Replace the cupboard front | Joinery contractor, 14 Oct 2026 | Front replaced; hinges adjusted | Wide and close-up photo, both named EX-A01; supplied by the contractor | None supplied | None stated | On 9 Oct the owner said the door catches when closing | M. K., 15 Oct 2026 | The front was replaced in the right place | Photos cannot show whether the door still catches | Request information: closing not confirmed | Contractor to confirm by 17 Oct; M. K. checks with the owner | 15 Oct: front replaced, closing being checked |
| EX-B02 · Apartment 11 · Bathroom, beside the shower tray | Loose tile edge | Refix or replace the loose tile | Tiling contractor, 16 Oct 2026 | “Done” | One unnamed close-up of a tile joint; no wider view | None supplied | None stated | None received yet | M. K., 17 Oct 2026 | Nothing case-specific: the photo could belong to several homes | Which home and tile, and what work was done | Request information: identity and scope missing | Contractor to resubmit by 20 Oct; M. K. reviews on receipt | 17 Oct: work is being checked, update by 21 Oct |
| EX-C03 · Apartment 7 · Bedroom, below the window | Dark mark that returned after cleaning | Find and address the source of the mark, then make good the finish | Contractor, 20 Oct 2026 | Wall repainted | One photo of the repainted wall | No assessment of the source recorded | Work on the source not described | The mark has come back before | M. K., 22 Oct 2026 | The finish was renewed | Whether the source was found or dealt with | Obtain specialist review; case stays open | Qualified person to say what evidence is needed; M. K. by 29 Oct | 22 Oct: case stays open, reason explained |
Scroll sideways to see every column.
This record is a proposed working aid, not a technical standard or a legal test. Add the columns your contract or warranty process requires.
Handle disagreement and later observations
When an owner disagrees with a repair, record their account in their own words and review it against the agreed work, just as you reviewed the contractor's report. Then record what the team decided, why, and what route the owner has next under your process.
Formal warranty processes also rely on this kind of record. In Ontario, Tarion's conciliation guidance says a homeowner who considers a builder's repairs inadequate can provide supporting information such as photographs or an expert report. In British Columbia, BC Housing says that after repairs under home warranty insurance the homeowner receives the repair specifications and a letter confirming the completion date, and it advises keeping repair letters and inspection notes. These are local processes. Your team's review is not a warranty provider's decision.
Silence is not evidence that the owner is satisfied. If you have not heard back, record that you told them the outcome and when, not that they accepted the work. If the same problem appears after closure, keep the earlier case and its review: recording a repeat repair explains how to link the new attempt to the old one.
Use the checklist proportionately
Match the evidence to the work. A description and labelled photos can confirm a visible replacement such as a cupboard front, though not how its door closes; a recurring problem needs more. Asking for the same heavy pack on every job slows small repairs without making larger ones any safer.
- Can we tell which case, home and location this is?
- Do we know what work was agreed, including any change?
- Does the evidence answer the review question for this work?
- Is anything outstanding, limited or still uncertain, and is it written down?
- Have we recorded who reviewed it, when and what they decided?
- Does the owner know the outcome and any next step?
Collect only what the decision needs. Photos taken in an occupied home can show belongings and people, so ask for the work area only and keep the record within your team's normal access. A ticked checklist records that someone looked; it is not technical certification. The method works the same in a spreadsheet or any portal.
Where this applies
For customer care and warranty teams at residential developers who review contractors' work on individual defects after handover. The method fits any market and any tool. It does not cover building-control completion certificates or project close-out. The checklist is Toveta's proposed working aid, not a technical standard or legal test: check your contractual and statutory obligations, and any warranty provider's process, with your adviser.
Sources
- Tarion. Conciliation process, assessment & resolution. Ontario, Canada; homeowner warranty process context only, checked 3 November 2026
- BC Housing. Home Warranty Insurance Claims. British Columbia, Canada; home warranty insurance claims only, checked 3 November 2026
Spotted an error or an outdated source? Email info@wisemonks.com and we will correct the page.
